Unpacking neurodivergent assessments: What is a diagnosis for?
The Neurodiversity Wise Blog
Unpacking neurodivergent assessments: What is a diagnosis for?
By Jannine Perryman ·

There is a question I hear increasingly often when people talk about ADHD and autism assessment:
“What if I just want to know?”
And my first response is: of course you are allowed to be curious about yourself.
You are allowed to recognise yourself in something you have read. You are allowed to wonder why certain things have always seemed harder for you than for other people. You are allowed to look back at childhood, school, relationships, work, parenting or simply everyday life and think:
Hang on. Could this explain something?
Curiosity is valuable.
But a clinical diagnosis has a different job to do.
And I think we sometimes muddle those two things together.
Diagnosis is not a personality quiz
Lots of people have ADHD traits.
Lots of people have autistic traits.
People forget things. Get distracted. Become overwhelmed. Prefer routines. Find some social situations difficult. Hyperfocus on things they enjoy. Procrastinate. Get intensely interested in particular subjects.
None of those things, by themselves, make somebody ADHD or autistic.
When clinicians assess ADHD, for example, they are not simply counting how many ADHD-like things somebody does. NICE guidance requires symptoms to be associated with meaningful impairment and to occur in more than one important area of life.
A phrase I have used for years is chronic and pervasive.
It is not a universal diagnostic phrase that can simply be applied to every neurodevelopmental condition, but it is useful shorthand for something important.
We are looking for patterns which are longstanding and which reach into life in meaningful ways.
Not:
“Do you sometimes lose your keys?”
But:
“What has attention, memory or organisation meant for your education, employment, finances, relationships, wellbeing or ability to manage daily life?”
Not simply:
“Do you dislike noisy places?”
But:
“What happens to you in those environments? What do you have to do to cope? What is the cost afterwards? What have you stopped doing because of it?”
The difference is important.
So what is a diagnosis actually for?
At its simplest, a diagnosis gives a name to a clinically meaningful pattern.
But that is only the beginning.
A useful assessment should help us understand something.
It might help explain why somebody has struggled despite trying extraordinarily hard.
It might identify support or reasonable adjustments.
It might influence treatment.
It might prompt further investigation.
It might change how somebody approaches work, education, relationships or parenting.
It might help another professional understand why a particular intervention has repeatedly failed.
It might give somebody language with which to advocate for themselves.
And, yes, it might profoundly change the way somebody understands their own life.
I don’t think we should be frightened of that last one.
Of course diagnosis can change how you understand yourself
A diagnosis should not become the explanation for every aspect of a human being.
You are not just ADHD.
You are not just autistic.
A diagnostic manual cannot tell us whether you are funny, kind, irritating, creative, cautious, adventurous, ambitious, generous or brilliant at making soup.
It cannot explain your culture, your family, the things that have happened to you, the people you love or the decisions you have made.
But it would be equally strange to say that something which affects the way a person attends, processes, communicates, regulates, senses and responds to their environment should have no place in how they understand themselves.
For some people, diagnosis rearranges decades of information.
The child who was always told they were lazy.
The teenager who could achieve brilliantly in one subject and seemingly not try in another.
The adult who has built increasingly complicated systems just to stay on top of ordinary life.
The person who has spent years wondering why everyone else appears to know rules they somehow missed.
The parent who suddenly recognises themselves while seeking support for their child.
Diagnosis does not rewrite what happened.
But sometimes it profoundly changes what we think those experiences meant.
That can matter.
“I just want to know”
This is where I think we need some nuance.
If somebody tells me, “I just want to know,” I am interested in the word just.
Because sometimes they really are curious.
But often there is much more sitting underneath it.
“I just want to know why I keep burning out.”
“I just want to know why school was so difficult when everyone thought I was capable.”
“I just want to know why I can run a business but can’t open my post.”
“I just want to know why I keep ending up overwhelmed.”
“I just want to know why relationships seem to require so much translation.”
“I just want to know why I have spent my whole life feeling as though everybody else was given an instruction manual.”
There is usually a story.
And part of good assessment is understanding that story.
Useful does not mean medical
There is another assumption worth challenging.
If diagnosis has to be useful, people sometimes hear:
There must therefore be a medical treatment.
No.
Medication is one possible intervention for ADHD, and for some people it can be enormously helpful.
But medical intervention is only one part of the picture.
NICE ADHD guidance includes environmental modifications, psychological support, education, employment considerations and non-pharmacological interventions alongside medication.
For an autistic person, the useful outcome might have nothing to do with medication at all.
It might be changing an environment.
Changing communication.
Using visual information.
Reducing unnecessary sensory load.
Having more processing time.
Accessing occupational therapy, speech and language support or another specialist assessment.
Changing working arrangements.
Understanding why a conventional therapeutic approach has not worked.
Building support around everyday life.
It might involve social prescribing: connecting somebody with community activities, peer support, physical activity, creative opportunities or practical sources of help which improve wellbeing and participation without medicalising the person.
Sometimes the most useful intervention is changing what is happening around them.
And sometimes diagnosis should lead to more questions
This, for me, is one of the most important parts.
A diagnosis should not become the point at which professional curiosity stops.
“They’re autistic” is not an explanation for everything an autistic person experiences.
Neither is:
“They have ADHD.”
Suppose an autistic person has very significant difficulties with daily living.
Why?
What is their intellectual profile?
What is happening with receptive and expressive language?
What about processing speed?
Motor planning?
Working memory?
Sensory processing?
Physical health?
Sleep?
Pain?
Epilepsy?
Trauma?
Anxiety?
Adaptive functioning?
Communication?
What does this person understand that they may not be able to demonstrate easily?
What happens when we change the environment?
The same principle applies to ADHD.
If somebody is struggling enormously, we should not automatically put every difficulty into an ADHD shaped box.
Could there also be dyslexia?
Developmental coordination difficulties?
Autism?
Language differences?
Trauma?
Sleep problems?
Anxiety?
Depression?
Hormonal changes?
A physical health problem?
Something else entirely?
This is one of the risks of diagnosis when it is used badly.
The ‘label’ answers the question and everybody stops looking.
But good assessment should do the opposite.
Diagnosis should open the file, not close it
I sometimes think we have expected diagnostic labels to do jobs they were never designed to do.
“Autism” cannot describe an entire autistic person.
“ADHD” cannot describe an entire ADHD person.
Even two people who meet exactly the same diagnostic criteria may have profoundly different lives, strengths, difficulties and support needs.
The diagnosis tells us something important.
Then we have to keep going.
What does this look like for you?
Where does it create difficulty?
Where might it create strength?
What have you already developed to compensate?
What is costing you far more effort than anybody can see?
What support would actually make a difference?
What else might we need to understand?
Those questions matter at least as much as the label.
Assessment should tell us more than yes or no
This is also why I am uncomfortable with assessment being treated simply as a gate through which somebody passes and emerges with either:
YES: ADHD
or
NO: NOT ADHD
A thoughtful assessment should give us information even when somebody does not meet diagnostic criteria.
Perhaps there are significant executive function difficulties but another explanation fits better.
Perhaps somebody has autistic characteristics but does not meet the threshold for diagnosis.
Perhaps assessment identifies another neurodevelopmental profile.
Perhaps trauma, health, language, learning or environmental factors need further exploration.
Perhaps the person needs support regardless of whether a particular diagnostic threshold is crossed.
A good assessment should increase understanding.
Otherwise, what exactly have we assessed?
There can be relief in knowing
I also don’t want us to minimise something simply because it cannot be prescribed.
Understanding matters.
There can be enormous relief in discovering that something you have spent decades interpreting as a moral failure has another explanation.
That doesn’t mean every difficulty disappears.
It doesn’t mean diagnosis becomes an excuse.
It doesn’t mean every part of your personality suddenly belongs to ADHD or autism.
And it certainly doesn’t mean that everyone has to make diagnosis part of their identity.
People are entitled to relate to their diagnoses in different ways.
For one person, ADHD might be central to how they understand themselves.
Another might regard it largely as clinically useful information.
Someone may proudly call themselves autistic.
Someone else may prefer to say they have a diagnosis of autism.
People get to decide what their own diagnoses mean to them.
Our job as professionals is not to dictate the correct emotional relationship somebody should have with that information.
It is to help make sure the information itself is robust, meaningful and useful.
Curiosity is a beginning
So, if you are wondering whether you might be ADHD, autistic or otherwise neurodivergent, I am not going to tell you that curiosity is somehow insufficient or inappropriate.
Curiosity is often exactly where understanding starts.
Be curious.
Read.
Listen.
Notice patterns.
Talk to people.
Think about childhood as well as now.
Think about what helps and what makes things harder.
But when we move from exploration into clinical diagnosis, we are asking a bigger question than:
“Do I recognise myself in this?”
We are asking:
Is there a longstanding neurodevelopmental pattern here that has meaningful consequences for this person’s life?
And then, importantly:
What becomes possible because we understand that now?
That may mean treatment.
It may mean adjustments.
It may mean further assessment.
It may mean changing an environment.
It may mean different support.
It may mean understanding why previous interventions did not work.
It may mean finally having the language to explain something that has been present for a very long time.
And sometimes it means knowing yourself differently.
That is not all a diagnosis is for.
But neither should we pretend it does not matter.
A diagnosis is not the whole story.
It should help us understand the story better.
And, at its best, it should change the questions we ask next.
Sources and further reading
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: diagnosis and management (NG87). NICE guidance requires ADHD diagnosis to be based on a full clinical and psychosocial assessment, developmental and psychiatric history, and evidence of clinically meaningful impairment occurring across important settings.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Autism spectrum disorder in adults: diagnosis and management (CG142). NICE recommends that comprehensive autism assessment considers developmental history, functioning across settings, physical and mental health, other neurodevelopmental conditions and sensory differences, and that the purpose and outcome of assessment are discussed with the person.
Royal College of Psychiatrists. Autism and mental health. The College describes autism diagnosis in relation to significant impact on everyday life and emphasises understanding individual strengths, challenges and support needs.
